Have you ever tucked a jar of homemade bone broth into the refrigerator, eagerly waited for it to chill…and then been disappointed when it stayed liquid instead of turning into a beautiful gel?
The good news is that making richly gelatinous bone broth isn’t a mystery. In fact, it comes down to just a few simple techniques that begin before the pot ever goes on the stove.
In this post, I’ll share the three essential tips that will help you make consistently gelatinous beef bone broth, along with a bonus tip that can make all the difference. Once you understand why bone broth gels, you’ll be able to make nourishing broth with confidence every time.
Affiliates note: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. My content may contain affiliate links to products and services. If you click through and make a purchase, I’ll receive a small commission. It does not affect the price you pay.
Table of Contents
- A Quick Glance:
- Why Doesn’t Bone Broth Gel?
- Tip #1: Choose the Right Combination of Bones
- Tip #2: Don’t Add Too Much Water
- Tip #3: Simmer—Don’t Boil
- Bonus Tip: Why Gelatin Matters
- Final Thoughts
- More Bone Broth Videos
- Get Bone In Meats from Shirttail Creek Farm
- Looking for Beef Bones?
- The Modern Pioneer Cookbook
- The Modern Pioneer Pantry
- Start Your Traditional Foods Journey
- Download Your Free 36-Page Pantry List
- Join the Traditional Foods Kitchen Academy
- Kitchen Academy Videos
- Shop for My Favorite Items
A Quick Glance:
If you want your beef bone broth to gel consistently, remember these three essentials:
- Choose the right combination of bones:
- Meaty bones
- Marrow bones
- High-cartilage bones
- Add only enough water to cover the bones by about 1 inch.
- Never boil bone broth for hours. Bring it to a boil briefly, skim the foam, then maintain a gentle simmer for about 12 hours.
Bonus Tip: A properly gelatinous bone broth isn’t just satisfying—it provides a wonderfully rich source of proteins from both meat and collagen that can help support a healthy digestive system.
Why Doesn’t Bone Broth Gel?
Many home cooks assume that if their broth doesn’t gel, they’ve somehow failed.
Not at all.
Even a broth that stays liquid is still nutritious. However, when bone broth develops that beautiful jelly-like consistency after chilling, it’s usually a sign that you’ve successfully extracted plenty of collagen from the bones.
Fortunately, getting there isn’t difficult once you understand the process.
Tip #1: Choose the Right Combination of Bones
The biggest secret to a richly gelatinous bone broth begins at the butcher counter. Rather than relying on just one type of bone, combine three different kinds to create both excellent flavor and a broad range of naturally occurring proteins.
Meaty Bones
Meaty bones provide rich beef flavor along with proteins from the muscle meat. Some excellent choices include:
- Beef shanks
- Neck bones
These bones also add wonderful color and depth to the finished broth.
Marrow Bones
Marrow bones contribute collagen from the bones themselves while also providing nutrient-rich marrow that can be enjoyed separately or stirred back into the finished broth.
High-Cartilage Bones
This is the category many people overlook—and it’s often the key to achieving a beautifully gelled broth. Excellent choices include:
- Oxtails
- Knuckle bones
- Patella (kneecap) bones
These bones contain abundant cartilage, which releases additional collagen during the long, gentle cooking process.
When all three types of bones are combined, they create a broth that is both deeply flavorful and wonderfully gelatinous.
Tip #2: Don’t Add Too Much Water
More water does not mean better broth. In fact, it’s one of the most common reasons bone broth fails to gel.
After arranging your bones and vegetables in the pot, add only enough water to cover everything by approximately one inch. That’s all you need.
Using significantly more water simply dilutes the collagen that is extracted from the bones. The broth will still be nourishing, but it may never develop that rich gel you’re hoping for.
Tip #3: Simmer—Don’t Boil
This is perhaps the most important cooking tip of all. Bone broth should never spend hours at a rolling boil. Instead:
- Bring the broth just to a boil.
- Skim away the foam that rises to the surface.
- Reduce the heat immediately.
- Maintain a very gentle simmer.
For beef bone broth, a temperature of approximately 180°F (82°C) is ideal. Think of it as an occasional gentle “bloop… bloop…” rather than vigorous bubbling.
A low, steady simmer allows the collagen to be extracted gradually while producing a clear, beautiful broth.
Bonus Tip: Why Gelatin Matters
The goal isn’t simply to create broth that looks impressive in the refrigerator. A richly gelatinous bone broth contains collagen from several different sources within the bones, resulting in a diverse protein profile. That gelatin also gives bone broth its silky texture and is one of the reasons traditional cooks have treasured it for generations.
When enjoyed regularly as part of a wholesome diet, bone broth is a comforting way to add nourishing homemade foods to your family’s table.
Final Thoughts
Making beautifully gelatinous bone broth doesn’t require expensive equipment or complicated techniques. Simply remember these three essentials:
- Choose the right mix of bones.
- Add only enough water to cover them.
- Simmer gently instead of boiling.
With those three habits in place, you’ll greatly increase your chances of opening the refrigerator the next morning to find a rich, flavorful broth that has transformed into the beautiful gel every traditional cook loves to see.
And if your broth doesn’t gel perfectly every single time, don’t be discouraged. It’s still wonderfully nutritious, and with just a few small adjustments, you’ll soon be making consistently rich, delicious bone broth you’ll be proud to serve.
More Bone Broth Videos
Best Bones for Making Beef Bone Broth (And How to Make It Affordable)
Learn about the best bones to create a rich, gelatinous beef bone broth and how to affordably combine the bones for flavor and nutrition.
Old-Fashioned Golden Sipping Broth for Cold Days
Discover this simple, old-fashioned way to enjoy homemade bone broth.
How to Make Rotisserie Chicken Bone Broth (Michelin Chef Inspired)
Transform a humble rotisserie chicken into deeply flavorful, gelatin-rich bone broth using a chef-inspired pressure-cooker method.
Get Bone In Meats from Shirttail Creek Farm
I’d like to introduce you to Shirttail Creek Farm, located in Brenham, Texas. They offer a wide range of grass-fed and finished beef, pastured pork, chicken, and eggs, and lots more through their online store.
In addition to Bone-In Chuck Roasts and Pastured Stewing Hens, you can find lots of nutritious meats and products to help you make the most healthy and gelatinous beef bone broth:
Looking for Beef Bones?
If you can’t find beef bones in your neighborhood supermarket or farmer’s market, check out US Wellness Meats.
- Use discount code MARYNEST and my link for a one-time 15% savings off regular-priced items on your US Wellness Meats order. You can shop for a variety of products, including:
This post is not sponsored. I’m a long-time customer of US Wellness Meats because I have always been impressed by the quality of their products. Check out my US Wellness Meats unboxing video to see the types of products you can get, including bones for beef bone broth!
Order YOUR COPY Now!
The Modern Pioneer Cookbook
Seasonal ingredients, traditional techniques, and nourishing recipes. Over 85 traditional, from-scratch recipes! Discover for yourself how you can use simple ingredients and traditional techniques to cook the modern pioneer way.
Order YOUR COPY Now!
The Modern Pioneer Pantry
Simple ingredients, timeless techniques, and a well-stocked pantry. Discover over 100 nourishing recipes to preserve food and turn pantry staples into homemade meals. Build a wholesome, traditional pantry—just like a modern pioneer!
Start Your Traditional Foods Journey
Sharing my passion for traditional cooking goes beyond my YouTube cooking school—it also comes to life in the pages of my cookbooks. Both of my books, The Modern Pioneer Cookbook and The Modern Pioneer Pantry, are proudly published by Penguin Random House.
The first is filled with time-honored recipes to help you create a traditional foods kitchen, while the second is your complete guide to home food preservation. Order both books today to start or continue your traditional foods journey.
Download Your Free 36-Page Pantry List
For an extensive list of the traditional foods you can make and purchase to stock your pantry, be sure to download my free 36-page Traditional Foods Pantry List. This comprehensive eBook is full of links to recipe videos, helpful articles, and more!
Join the Traditional Foods Kitchen Academy
Are you looking for more traditional foods videos? If so, I invite you to join the Traditional Foods Kitchen Academy. Members of this optional paid YouTube community get access to exclusive videos and other members-only perks. Plus, your YouTube comments include a special members-only badge.
Kitchen Academy Videos
Baking Questions Answered with Ted and Me!
Join me and my husband Ted for a Q&A filled with practical kitchen tips, helpful techniques, and answers to your baking questions.
Baking with Whole Grains: The Maslin Method, Grain Mills, and America’s Bread Basket
Explore whole grain baking with The Maslin Method, fresh-milled flour, grain mills, heritage wheats, and more.
A Sweet Season of Celebration and New Beginnings with The Maslin Method Baking School Series
Celebrate the close of a heartfelt book tour and the exciting launch of The Maslin Method Baking School for traditional baking.
Stay in Touch with Mary’s Nest
- Subscribe to My YouTube Channel for Traditional Foods Videos (Free) - When you subscribe, be sure to click on the notification bell that will let you know each time I upload a new video.
- Subscribe to Mary’s Traditional Foods Newsletter (Free) - Get a free 36-page eBook for signing up: How to Stock Your Essential Traditional Foods Four-Corners Pantry.
- Join the Traditional Foods Kitchen Academy - For more detailed videos and exclusive members-only perks, join my YouTube membership community.
- Order The Modern Pioneer Cookbook - Get a hardcover book of Mary's nourishing recipes from a Traditional Foods Kitchen. This bestselling cookbook is published by Penguin Random House with their DK imprint.
- Order The Modern Pioneer Pantry - Get Mary's latest hardcover cookbook about preserving food and making delicious meals from your Four Corners Pantry. Mary's second cookbook is also published by Penguin Random House.
I look forward to having you join me in my Texas Hill Country Kitchen!
Shop for My Favorite Items
Favorite Kitchen Supplies
- Favorite Aprons
- Spice Grinder
- Countertop Burner (On my kitchen island in many recipe videos.)
- Handheld Vacuum Sealing System
- Vacuum Lids
- Whisk
- Silica Gel Packets (Helps keep moisture from building up in your mix)
- Cast Iron Dutch Oven
- 8-Quart Slow-Cooker
- Fat Separator (Clever kitchen device to help you decant bone broth)
- Flour Sack Towels
- pH Strips (Helps you check on the acidity of your vinegar)
Amazon Shop and Shopping Guide
- Visit Mary’s Nest Amazon Shop
- Get a 30-day Audible trial with a free audiobook
- Visit my Shopping Guide page
Get up to 15% off for stocking your Traditional Foods Pantry and equipping your Modern Pioneer Kitchen, including discounts from US Wellness Meats, Farmhouse Teas, Backwoods Home, Masontops, Cultures for Health, Survival Garden Seeds, Redmond Real Salt, and More!
